Taxis and Picket Lines

Carleton University staff are on strike. Classes continue, but picket lines are set up. Unfortunately, by the first day, there had been an incident. A couple of picketers were hit by cars. The picketers are okay, thankfully, and I won’t judge whether it was malice or negligence (or a mixture of the two).

Of note to people heading to Carleton, OC Transpo buses are not going on to campus. The O-train and Para-Transpo will, but regular buses will not. I wondered what the reason was behind this decision, as the website gave no explanation. So I tweeted OC Transpo. Quickly, I received this response:

This is a reasonable explanation. It could be convenient cover so that OC Transpo can escape controversy. News reports also stated that some taxis would not cross the picket line, as some drivers are unionized.

Which is also reasonable…almost.

The ability of labour to organize is an important freedom that provides safeguards against economic power structures that might otherwise oppress them. It’s not exactly 1919 out there, but in our capitalist system, power dynamics tend to tilt in favour of the owners of capital rather than the providers of labour. Pooling workers’ economic power helps to level out this power imbalance.

Taxi drivers, however, are not a completely powerless class of worker. In Ottawa, the taxi industry is heavily regulated through its plate system. The city bars new entrants to the market unless they can get a taxi plate, which tend to sell on the market four five- or six-figures. Owners of plates can make a good bit of coin either by selling, leasing or otherwise leveraging their plates. The economic rents that are extracted are enormous.

This is a system that insulates and protects current industry participants against new competition. It also allows certain actors to get rich through government privilege. Riders (customers) have their options artificially limited by municipal ordinance, and are held hostage to the whims of drivers and taxi companies.

Taxis benefit tremendously* from this privileged status; it is only reasonable to expect them to do the very thing that the government prevents others from doing.

*If you are unsure that they benefit tremendously, you need only look at the extensive lobbying efforts of the taxi industry to maintain this racket.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Taxis and Picket Lines

  1. The same thing can be said for any government quota system. Ottawa Taxis and ontario milk come to mind. While not really defending the quota system it does afford some reliability in supply. It also gives workers a chance to buy jobs with some chance of a retirement plan at the end. There have been many suggestions about how to change the system, particularly in Ottawa, the is some jurisprudence in this regard dating back to the 1980’s I believe. I am not really offering much here. The taking away of long established government rights seems to be always met with arguments of financial hardship should those rights be revoked. Buying back the licenses or quota from every taxi driver or milk farmer maybe one way to do it but how much are we willing to pay as a city or province to do this.

  2. Pingback: Taxis, Supply Management and Speculation | Steps from the Canal

  3. Pingback: The Tyranny of Taxis | Steps from the Canal

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s